Environmental Justice
North State communities have not been sufficiently represented in commonly used tools for representing disadvantaged communities, often due to low population and mismatch of urban indicators (like traffic) with rural concerns (like wildfire risk). CalEnviroScreen classifies no communities as disadvantaged in the North State despite clear evidence of disadvantage.
Trinity County Perspective
Despite clear evidence of poverty, wildfire exposure, and health access gaps, state environmental justice tools like CalEnviroScreen classify zero communities in the North State — including all of Trinity County — as disadvantaged. This isn't because the disadvantage doesn't exist; it's because the tool was designed around urban indicators like traffic density and proximity to industrial facilities, which miss rural realities like wildfire risk, geographic isolation, and limited healthcare access. For a county of 15,600 people spread across rugged terrain, this classification failure means lost access to state funding streams tied to "disadvantaged community" status.
A North State-specific environmental justice mapping tool is under development with UC Davis, layering demographics with health, fire, transportation, and socioeconomic vulnerabilities. This is directly relevant to Trinity County, where the overlap of wildfire exposure, Native population health disparities, and limited infrastructure should register clearly once measured with appropriate indicators. County leaders should track this tool's release and ensure Trinity County data is accurately represented, then use the resulting maps to pursue funding and policy attention that CalEnviroScreen currently blocks. Engaging local youth in this process — another recommended action — could build long-term capacity in a county where civic participation infrastructure is thin.
High Priority Actions
3In partnership with UC Davis, layer demographics with health, fire, transportation, socioeconomic vulnerabilities. Maps available September 2024.
Use maps, visual aids, and tools to share with residents, planners, officials, NGOs to kickstart mitigation strategies
Share EJ issues within North State context rather than comparing to statewide issues. Inform community members and policymakers about unique challenges.
Challenges
5- CalEnviroScreen tool fails to identify any disadvantaged communities in North State
- Methodological mismatch between urban-focused indicators and rural realities
- Low population levels hiding disadvantaged status
- Overlap between Native population density and health care availability shortages
- Water allocation system issues in underserved areas like Modoc County
Opportunities
4- North-State-specific EJ tool under development with UC Davis
- Youth engagement in environmental justice planning
- Graduate student research on water allocation and forest fire policy
- Cultural resilience connected to long-term economic development
All Recommendations
1UCD researchers developing project to engage North State youth in envisioning equitable, sustainable economic development